David Bowie is described as “the best-smelling human I ever met”, by Arcade Fire musician Will Butler.
The Thin White Duke's fumes came up in Butler's conversation with BBC 6 Music's morning goddess Lauren Laverne last week while promoting his debut solo album Policy.
Never one to let an intriguing detail slip away, Laverne pounced, insisting firmly, “I am going to require some more adjectives. How would you describe the smell of David Bowie?”
Butler replied:
You walk into a room, and you're like, “Something's different. I'm in a different dimension. It smells so good in here!” [And then you realize] “Oh, David Bowie's here.”
It smelled like if an ancient pine forest had a massive forest fire -- but like, a month ago. So you get the new growth of the grass and the moisture, but still there's an undercurrent of pain. But also of smoke, so kind of like marshmallows...? It's powerful.
So what was David Bowie wearing? To me, “smoky, month-old pine forest fire” says Annick Goutal Encens Flamboyante loud and clear. But that misses out on the grass, moisture...and marshmallows.
Let's put our noses together, people, and figure this out.
To get us started, let's flash back to Ziggy-era Bowie. In this 1973 Mick Rock photo, there's a tantalizing glimpse of a Dior bottle nestled next to the bananas on David's backstage dressing table.
Both Diorissimo and Miss Dior came in the black and white houndstooth splash bottle with its jaunty bow tie. I'm sure Ziggy Stardust would have made an appropriate conveyance system for either.
UPDATE:
After Bowie's too-sad passing on 10 January 2016 (which has left me in a melancholic fog that I can't shake), here's an update on the man's perfume circa 2005, via musician Owen Pallett, who posted this on Facebook:
In 2005 he invited Arcade Fire to play some shows with him, and Bowie offered to take the band out for dinner. Most of the band had other plans (?), so it was literally me, Patrick, Win, Regine, Will and Jenny having dinner at a place on Avenue A with Bowie and his manager Coco.
Me and Patrick were sitting across from Bowie, and Bowie and I hit it off insanely and talked about Mishima...and This Heat and all sorts of stuff. Patrick hit it off with Bowie too, they talked mostly about fashion and furniture design.
We talked abut his smoking habit (he told me he'd quit a year before he had his heart attack). He was wearing Creed Silver Mountain Water cologne which is wonderful but too ostentatious for anyone but Bowie to ever get away with.
Owen goes on to say that “no words could really describe the man's complete generosity of spirit, intelligence and charisma.”
This new world without David Bowie in it feels a little less special.
Read Pallett's full post here.
Hi Katie,
ReplyDeleteThis is fascinating!
Not sure exactly what it is but sharing my ideas -
My first thought was that it sounds like Ormonde Woman. It has that grassy, pine forest with darkness (pain?) as weel as spun sugar. Not sure it smells like it burnt down though.
Then I thought perhaps Bois d'Encens by Armani. It has that smokey forest vibe but no marshmallows.
Finally I'm wondering if it could be Fille En Aiguilles by Serge Lutens. It's a slightly smokey pine forest with a little sweetness, though that's more fruity than marshmallow-y.
Dying to know what it is. Looking forward to others' thoughts.
Hi Tara! Hey, those are good thoughts! I take your Ormonde Woman and raise you Ormonde Man. That's even more piney.
DeleteNow I have an idea that Tauer L'Air du Desert Marocain could fit the bill. It's smoky, with a cola sweetness.
I just started wearing Tauer L'Air du Desert Marocain, and I get a little lightheaded with happiness when it starts developing on my skin. I feel like being able to make yourself swoon is always a good sign, right? Now, if DB wears it, I may start buying the stuff by the case. *fans self*
DeleteI dig ya, Tai - the idea that you could make yourself smell just like your favorite and most-cherished cultural god or goddess is heady stuff!
Deletehello earthings, Ziggy Stardust here! I just wanted you to know that i like the picture of me.
DeleteHe uses Sycomore by Chanel Les Exclusif
ReplyDeleteDense, grassy and smoky, that one, while still being light on its feet. A solid contender.
DeleteYong, how do you know? You sound pretty definitive! Thanks.
DeleteAccording to his official web-site, Minotaure by Paloma Picasso, which he says, "is hard to find, so he stocks up. He also like anything by Guerlain."
ReplyDeleteWhen I interviewed perfumer Michel Almairac several years ago, he cited Minotaure as one of his favorite creations. (You can check out the Almairac interview here.)
DeleteUnfortunately Minotaur has been reformulated....I am sure he was a fan of the old formula. The new is a shadow. :/
DeleteSame, discouraging old story...
DeleteHmm. Interesting. I think someone who wasnt familiar with vetiver might describe it that way, so Sycomore fits. I'm unfamiliar with Minotaur.
ReplyDeleteYeah! I'm intrigued by how Will Butler (presumably not a self-identifying fumehead) just plunged in to paint a word picture of the fragrance. A fine imagination at work.
DeleteIt's Zino by Davidoff! Well, in 1988 it was.
ReplyDeleteWell, how many different looks has Bowie had since 1988? He will have cycled through plenty of fragrance concepts since then...
DeletePossibly Sycomore, Timbuktu, Rien, CDG 2 Men, or good old Vetiver Guerlain?
ReplyDeleteWhat a great description.
Cybele
I love the description, Cybele - and your suggestions! Guerlain Vetiver has been my winter comfort scent.
DeleteThe marshmallow note throws me a bit. Maybe Sonoma Scent Studio Incense Pure, Amber Fetiche or Aftelier Ancient (Resins although that one is owned by Mr. Cohen!)
ReplyDeleteI'm also thrown by the marshmallow, Brooke. I'm wondering if Will said it as a result of an association with smoke and campfires, rather than the literal smell of burning marshmallows.
DeleteIf so, your suggestions are fine ones. And the Amber Fetiche even gets a tad actual marshmallow-y with its sweet vanilla-ness.
I can only come up with on thing.... Oh wait it's on the tip of my tongue....no it's gone........Wait! YES! .... Divin`Enfant Etat Libre d`Orange
ReplyDeleteJust read up on this on LuckyScent - what an oddity! Will seek it out for a sniff...
DeleteHey Katie,
ReplyDeleteThis article is indeed intriguing! I saw it posted originally in the Facebook group DAVID BOWIE Official. Btw do you think, you've finally worked out what the Legend, himself is currently wearing? :)
It's an ongoing forensic study.
DeleteSome more thoughts...Patchouli 24 could relate to the burned marshmellow but then grass and moisture are missing. I am also thinking of Le Labo's Vetiver and maybe French Lover. I am so curious! Cybele
ReplyDeleteThe more suggestions you all make, the more intriguing this becomes...
DeleteI immediately thought of Bois d'Ascese when I read that description, but given how recent this perfume is, it will depend on when exactly Butler smelled Bowie. Also Arso came to mind, but we've got the same problem.
ReplyDeleteI know Bowie and Arcade Fire worked together in the last couple of years, so it is possible that the Naomi Goodsir perfume could be a contender.
DeleteMaybe he layered?
ReplyDeleteYeah, layering would allow for any number of "perfume math" combinations to get to the beautiful fug that Will Butler reported.
DeleteCreed Silver Mountain Water. Odd though, as a male scent should whisper but never shout. So they must have been very close! I smelt the amazing Mr Bowie in a Cork street gallery once, and he smelt heavily of tobacco. Years later I met him again and no particular odour but he was wearing a green-faced Paul Smith watch which for some reason I've never forgotten. Finally at the Riverside studios and he was sweating during a performance under hot lights.....
ReplyDeleteOoh, good Bowie sightings (and smellings), Richard!
DeleteHis name is not "Will" Butler, it is *Win Butler as in Edwin.
ReplyDeleteI agree that it sounds like ELdO's Divin Enfant or a layered combination.
Will Butler is the brother of Win Butler.
DeleteNaw, the Butler here in question is Will - check the links, yo. Win's bro has a side project going, and was a very entertaining interviewee on Lauren Laverne's 6 Music show.
DeleteRe Divin Enfant - you've given the second vote for it...sounds like a solid contender...
It could be Guerlain's Aqua Allegoria Winter Delices.
ReplyDeleteHmmm, pine-y. I totally see Dave wearing a Lutens. Fille en Aiguilles? Idk if it fits campfire smell. Perhaps it's more of a pine-y incense. Which then, Idk off-hand what it could be.
ReplyDeleteF e A from Lutens is good - it's forest-y and sweet at the same time.
DeleteHey Katie ;-) I'm a huge fan of Molecule 01 and I was wondering if as today there's a new buzz similar to this fragrance, you know since 2006, I also wear Joe Malone's Lime Basil & Mandarin. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteDan
Dan, Molecule 01 continues to dominate the world of perfume. I don't have facts and figures, but I do know from chatting to the fume jockeys at Liberty London and Scent Bar that it's their best-selling fragrance.
DeleteNothing released since has come close in popularity and in capturing the public's imagination, both conceptually and how it smells.
+1 Profvmvm Roma Arso
ReplyDeleteHighly unlikely and obscure, but it does sound quite a bit like Phonecia's Far NWest. It has the wet and dry woods and the roasted marshmallows. Only a bit smoky, though, and with a lot of skunk (yes, really).
ReplyDeleteI love the description. Surely someone reading this knows Mr Bowie well enough to ask???
ReplyDeleteAblaze by Boadicea sounds kind of like this. R.I.P., Bowie. Now I'll never get to smell you, alas!
ReplyDeleteIt is just so sad to say goodbye to David Bowie. I can't really get my head around it.
Delete"Marshmallows" sounds a bit abstract, as though a smoky smell might be reminiscent of roasting marshmallows.
ReplyDeleteIf he literally got the impression of marshmallows, maybe Bowie was layering a gourmand with a green fragrance?
I suspect an overall smoky smell that alluded to marshmallows, rather than a full-on blast of Pink Sugar.
DeletePerhaps his fragrance was mixed with cigarette?
ReplyDeleteThe campfire and marshmallow leads me to think something like Diptyque's Galliano room spray. That's a great one. The iris/vanilla is marshmallow, but since it's also mixed with a burning fireplace of pine...
Anyway, just a thought.
The Naomi Goodsir also comes to mind.
It seems Bowie had packed in the smoking by the time we was working with Arcade Fire.
DeleteYour suggestions are really creative!
Perhaps Byredo Gypsy Water?
ReplyDeleteThat's a good, mellow one.
DeleteSans marshmallows, it sounds like Norne by Slumberhouse.
ReplyDeleteI need to check out this Portland OR line. Portland is one of the best cities I've every visited.
DeleteBowie wore Minotaure by Paloma Picasso and Floris of London. Not sure which specific one this article describes, but my guess would be "Elite" based on the description. here's a link: http://www.florislondon.com/en_usd/elite-eau-de-toilette
ReplyDeleteI'd love to read the article. Do you remember where you saw it?
DeleteOver the last couple of years I have bought my husband samples based on this list (and some other casual internet research). He's a Bowie fan and it's been a lot of fun having him smelling like Bowie. His favourites so far are Minotaure and Guerlain's Vetiver. Smelling and wearing them has been a nice way of remembering and paying tribute this week. Thanks to all for the suggestions.
ReplyDeleteOoh, I didn't know Vetiver was in Bowie's rotation! I've been having a love affair with that one for the past year.
DeleteNot sure the interview, but Bowie said in the 70s he and someone were always experimenting with layering scents.
ReplyDeleteI would love to track down that interview! I wonder if the "someone" was Brian Eno, who is known for being a fumehead.
DeleteYes I was thinking this - he surely would have done some nasal jazzin' with Mr E.
ReplyDeleteMight he have had a personal Guerlain or whathaveyou composed?
I would, in his shooz. He must have dallied with most of the Guerlains, of all genders.
This is an important mission, on which we must find some concrete data!
I just love old pictures/glimpses in film of dressing tables & perfume collections, over which I like to pause & obsess.
I think Ziggy would have gone with Diorella - also a houndstooth.
I love to think of Ziggy in a cloud of Diorella. If only because that used to be one of my go-to's.
DeleteI read on a website that someone met him in Montreux in the 90s and he was very perfumed and Bowie said that he was wearing Thierry Muglers A*MEN. That one is smooth and sweet with kinky smoky undertones. I hope that one is true coz to me that is the scent of Bowie, I can definitely imagine it on Jareth. What do you think? michele
ReplyDeleteMichele, I'll bet someone with Bowie's appreciation for complexity and jarring contrasts got a kick out of A*Men. Chameleon that he was, he probably had a whole wardrobe of smells - for all his looks, moods and modes.
DeleteDior Homme Intense and Guerlain Habit Rouge have a soft marshmallow bounce in them. Habit Rouge in particular has an edible element (always a plus) and it's very 90's so maybe it ties in? Great blog, Katie, I've had fun reading the non-serious fragrantature, Tspora x
ReplyDeleteThanks, Tspora! Those are both lovely smells. I wear Habit Rouge from time to time.
DeleteAmouage Interlude fits that description
ReplyDelete"Bowie offered to take the band out for dinner. Most of the band had other plans..."
ReplyDeleteWHAT?
WHAT IN THE NAME OF GOD?!
I could literally be scheduled for major surgery, childbirth or my own wedding, and I would still get a rain check and bail in order to accept a dinner invitation from DAVID BOWIE.
Oh my god. Who ARE these people.
Mary Anne Hobbs (6Music) recently on air described meeting Bowie & him smelling of L'eau D'Issey Pour Homme. Unsure of time period.
ReplyDeleteGood intel!
ReplyDeleteKatie, I thought (hoped) you were coming back to youtube?? I dearly hope you and your family are well in these awful times, still keeping my fingers crossed.xx
ReplyDeleteHi Katie
ReplyDeletewhich perfume would you recommend to remind me of the Almalfi coast
i would have been in sorrento this summer not the same sat next to my small pond in cloudy oxfordshire
Hello. I just wanted to say that I love the pictures you pictures u picked out for this. P.S. I am Ziggy and I come from Mars.
ReplyDeleteApparently he wore Tom Ford Grey Vetiver, according to a recent interview with Iman.
ReplyDeleteHe wore (recently before he passed) Tom Fords Grey Veviter. His wife Iman said her new perfume is a combo of TFGV and her favorite perfume. Side note: Prince wore Givenchy Pi
ReplyDelete